Roy Keane SLAMS Crystal Palace Star Jean-Philippe Mateta: “Get Rid of Him” After Another Poor Display
Roy Keane has once again sparked controversy with a blistering critique of Crystal Palace striker Jean-Philippe Mateta, labelling the £75,000-a-week forward “overrated” and urging manager Oliver Glasner to take drastic action after yet another underwhelming performance — this time in Palace’s 2-0 defeat to Newcastle United. �
Sky Sports
The renowned pundit was scathing in his assessment, placing the blame squarely on Mateta’s shoulders for Crystal Palace’s continued struggles in key moments of big matches. Keane argued that his lack of influence in decisive games is now a glaring issue for the team. “He’s behind all counter goals, get rid of him,” Keane declared in a no-holds-barred review of the match. His remarks have reignited debate around Mateta’s future at Selhurst Park — and whether Palace should be seeking reinforcements up front.
Striker Under Fire After Newcastle Setback
Mateta started for Palace in the Premier League clash at St James’ Park but failed to make the impact expected of a senior frontman. Despite getting minutes on the pitch, he offered little threat against a well-organised Newcastle defence — one that capitalised on Palace’s lapses to score twice and preserve the Magpies’ strong home form. �
Sky Sports
Keane was quick to highlight that this wasn’t an isolated poor showing, but part of a concerning pattern:
“He wasn’t himself, it’s clear to everyone.”
What might have been an attempt to soften the blow instead underscored Keane’s belief that Mateta’s struggles are becoming familiar to supporters and pundits alike.
Mental Fragility in Big Moments?
Perhaps the most cutting critique came when Keane touched on what he sees as Mateta’s mental shortcomings.
“He’s always anxious when it comes to big games.”
For a club fighting to climb the Premier League table and deliver consistent results, issues in front of goal are doubly costly. Keane argues that Palace need a striker who can dictate games rather than one who shrinks when the spotlight is brightest — a role he believes Mateta has failed to fill.
A £75,000-a-Week Wage Bill Without Production
Another pillar of Keane’s critique was Mateta’s hefty wage compared to his contribution on the pitch. “When you’re earning that kind of money,” Keane insisted, “you should be leading the line, not disappearing in key moments.”
The French forward joined Palace with an impressive track record, but his recent form has left fans and critics questioning whether the club is getting value for money. With Palace struggling to convert chances and protect leads, offensive firepower is a priority — and Keane is unconvinced Mateta is the solution.
His most blunt verdict might have been the most provocative:
“He should be playing for a Championship team.”
Such a stark statement from one of English football’s most respected voices has done more than stir headlines — it has intensified pressure on both the player and Palace’s coaching staff.
Time for a Change Under Glasner?
The spotlight now turns to Oliver Glasner, who must decide whether to stick with Mateta as the main attacking threat or seek alternatives during the transfer window. Palace have shown flashes of promise this season, but inconsistency — particularly in finishing and game-deciding moments — continues to hold the side back.
Glasner’s tactical setup demands a forward who can influence the rhythm of play, hold up the ball under pressure, and finish chances clinically. Keane’s comments suggest that Mateta, for all his experience and physical presence, might not be that player at this stage.
A Crossroads for Player and Club
Whether you agree with Roy Keane’s assessment or consider it too harsh, one thing is certain: the conversation about Jean-Philippe Mateta’s place in this Crystal Palace side is heating up. The striker’s response on the pitch in coming weeks could define not only his future at Selhurst Park but also the club’s trajectory in the relentless Premier League campaign.