GARY NEVILLE STUNS SKY SPORTS AS HE RIPS INTO £75K-A-WEEK “OVERRATED” CRYSTAL PALACE STAR, QUESTIONS HIS CONFIDENCE AND URGES OLIVER GLASNER TO REPLACE HIM
Gary Neville left the Sky Sports studio in stunned silence after delivering a blistering critique of Crystal Palace goalkeeper Remi Mathew, questioning his confidence, composure, and overall suitability at Premier League level. The outspoken pundit did not hold back, suggesting Palace boss Oliver Glasner must urgently look elsewhere if the club wants to move forward.
Analysing Palace’s latest performance, Neville zeroed in on Mathew’s uncertainty between the posts, arguing that a goalkeeper earning £75,000 a week must inspire confidence — not anxiety — across the back line.
“For me, Remi Mathew looks like a goalkeeper low on belief,” Neville said. “Every decision feels rushed, every moment under pressure looks uncomfortable. That spreads fear through the defence.”
Neville was particularly critical of Mathew’s positioning and hesitation, claiming it has cost Palace control in key moments.
“Goalkeepers are leaders,” Neville added. “When the man behind you doesn’t look sure of himself, everything becomes shaky. At this level, that’s unacceptable.”
The former Manchester United defender questioned how long Palace can persist with Mathew as a dependable option, especially with the club trying to establish a new identity under Oliver Glasner.
“This is the Premier League — not a development league,” Neville continued. “You either perform or you’re replaced. Right now, I don’t see a keeper who wins you points.”
Neville also dismissed arguments that Mathew’s struggles are purely down to the defensive unit in front of him, insisting top goalkeepers elevate those around them.
“Great goalkeepers make saves they’re not supposed to,” he said. “They calm the game, command the box, and take responsibility. I’m not seeing any of that.”
Turning his attention to Glasner, Neville urged the Palace manager to be ruthless if progress is to be made.
“Glasner has to be brave,” Neville concluded. “If Remi Mathew is one of your higher earners and he’s not delivering confidence or consistency, you replace him. Simple.”
The comments have sparked fierce debate among Crystal Palace supporters, with many admitting concerns have been growing over Mathew’s performances. While his shot-stopping ability has shown flashes, Neville’s assessment highlights a bigger issue — belief.
As Palace look to stabilize and push higher up the table, the pressure is now firmly on Remi Mathew to respond. Otherwise, Oliver Glasner may be forced to make a decisive call in the transfer market — sooner rather than later.