Howard Webb Addresses Nick Walsh’s Controversial Calls in Old Firm Derby
Howard Webb, Chief Refereeing Officer for England’s Professional Game Match Officials Limited (PGMOL), has broken his silence on the officiating controversies surrounding Scottish referee Nick Walsh during Sunday’s fiery Old Firm derby at Celtic Park.The highly anticipated clash between Celtic and Rangers on May 10, 2026, was marred by several contentious decisions that have drawn intense scrutiny. Walsh, appointed as the match referee, faced criticism for at least three major calls, most notably allowing Hyun-Jun Yang’s equaliser for Celtic despite what many observers believed was a clear foul in the build-up. Additional flashpoints included a yellow card instead of a red for a challenge on Rangers goalkeeper Jack Butland and inconsistent application of VAR reviews.
In his verdict, Webb described elements of the officiating as “catastrophic” and has called for sanctions on the referee and involved VAR officials. The PGMOL chief, known for his push for greater transparency and accountability since taking his role in 2022, is understood to be pushing for disciplinary measures, including possible demotion, additional training, or suspension.Webb’s intervention highlights the cross-border implications of refereeing standards. While Walsh operates primarily in the Scottish system, Webb’s comments underscore a broader commitment to high standards across British football. He has previously introduced public explanations of key decisions and held officials accountable for repeated errors.The Old Firm derby, already one of the most intense fixtures in world football, saw passions run high both on and off the pitch. Rangers fans and pundits have been vocal in their condemnation, with some accusing officials of bias, while Celtic supporters largely defended the referee’s performance.Webb’s strong stance sends a clear message: poor decision-making, even in high-pressure derbies, will not go unpunished. As the season reaches its climax, his leadership will be closely watched to see whether such interventions lead to tangible improvements in refereeing consistency and fairness.