Manchester City take control at St. James’ Park
Manchester City delivered a clinical performance at St. James’ Park to beat holders Newcastle United 2-0 in the first leg of their Carabao Cup semi-final tie. Antoine Semenyo opened the scoring in the 53rd minute, continuing an impressive start to life in sky blue, while Rayan Cherki sealed the victory deep into stoppage time to give Pep Guardiola’s side a healthy advantage heading into the second leg at the Etihad.
City controlled phases of the match and capitalised on their opportunities — unlike Newcastle, who struggled to find a cutting edge in the final third. Semenyo’s goal came from close range after sustained pressure and slick build-up play, and Cherki’s late strike, finished off a rapid City break, ensured the visitors would head home in the lead.
—
Wissa misses big chance, Newcastle frustrated
Newcastle had their moments, particularly in the first half and the early stages after the break, but failed to capitalise. Yoane Wissa squandered one of the Magpies’ best openings — a crucial chance to give Newcastle the lead — when his header looped just over the bar, a miss that summed up a frustrating night for the forward.
Bruno Guimarães also struck the woodwork, and Newcastle’s efforts were repeatedly thwarted by City goalkeeper James Trafford, who made several important saves. The hosts ended the night having hit the post and put four promising openings wide — none of which found the back of the net.
—
VAR controversy and tactical narratives
The game was marked by controversy as City had a second goal ruled out after a lengthy VAR review due to an offside call involving Erling Haaland. That decision sparked debate among pundits and supporters alike.
Newcastle boss Eddie Howe will be disappointed with his side’s lack of cutting precision and will need a much sharper attacking display in the return leg if the Magpies are to defend their Carabao Cup crown. City, meanwhile, can approach next month’s second leg with confidence and a clear path to a potential final.